Peter Nicholson is a former Deputy Chief of Staff for Policy in the Office of the Prime Minister of Canada and currently serves as Chair of the Board of the Canadian Climate Institute.
A very useful contribution to the debate, shifting the focus on the oil industry willingness to commit large amount of capital in greenfield production, not on its transportation by pipeline.
As a now long retired petroleum economist I find this article to be most accurate in all respects. A couple of tangential points: the current level of oil sands production results from the huge investments over largely the period 2005 - 2015. This growth was significantly assisted by taxpayers and resource owners through tax and royalty relief. Many see this relief as a subsidy. I am one of these. The production growth from these subsidies has been impressive. However these subsidies brought on line higher cost production that would have otherwise been uncompetitive, and they lead to increased costs for all sectors of the economy. There is a fine line between subsidizing and assisting. Industry will always see regulatory relief and taxpayer input as justified and never as a subsidy. Industry too will see the correct policy desire for Canada to become an energy superpower as an opportunity to squeeze a few more dollars out of taxpayers. By the way, Canada already is a world energy superpower! A final word on subsidies/taxpayer help. It is entirely legitimate for governments to assist industry expansion. A question in this regard is: will taxpayers be entitled to a return on their investment or will their investment simply be a subsidy.
People are finally starting to ask the right question. Do the oil sands producers want this pipeline? All evidence to date demonstrates a complete lack of enthusiasm.
As noted, there is over one million barrels per day of new or optimized pipeline capacity in the pipeline, so to speak. That's almost a 30% increase over current production. This ephemeral pipeline will serve the next million barrels, an almost 60% increase in production in less than a decade! The total price will be well over $100 billion, dwarfing the costs of the pipeline itself, at a time when companies are relentlessly cutting costs.
If the producers aren't willing to declare their full support for this initiative then why is this farce, and the divisiveness it is causing, allowed to continue?
And.......a business case for a future oilsands expansion would need to include the cost of cleanup, which this time, we should insist is paid during the fe9nt end of production.
That's also something that would affect production in the current brownfield. As they mature, the amount set aside for clean up increases. Which might affect some operations production schedule.
I would urge the Feds to believe this. And just ... call their bluff. Mollify your green fans by saying that you're calling a bluff, that you don't believe they'll take you up on this: drop the CCS requirement entirely, drop the tanker ban, for any project that sells newly-produced oil.
Take away their scapegoat. Reveal the simple truth in this article: the business case has gone. And it is not coming back.
Every 2 million eVs sold reduce the global oil demand by just 0.1Mbbl/d. But they will sell about 24M eVs this year, and take 1.2Mbbl/d away from the market. Batteries have progressed to where China and some other countries are electrifying trucks, too; and ferries; and short-haul cargo boats. The Hormuz Crisis has only stimulated this switch.
‘the tanker ban’ is the dogmatic warcry of the misinformed - fed by the likes of Andrew Sheer, Smith & Poilievre Inc - sure.. just Delete International Navigational Law re some of the most Dangerous Waters on Spaceship Earth & why in hell would an actual Supertanker Skipper want to ? To go exactly where ? Delivering or picking up what Load ?
The elephant in the room needs to be addressed. For the actual owners of the oil sands, the status quo—where they control both the tap and the drain—is exactly how they maximize global profit.
The conventional political argument in Canada is that without an Asian outlet, Canadian heavy crude (Western Canadian Select, or WCS) suffers from a steep price discount compared to US West Texas Intermediate (WTI), hurting the Canadian economy.
While a wide WCS-WTI discount hurts a pure upstream producer, it is a massive windfall for a refiner configured to process heavy, sour crude. Because Canadian majors own the US refineries processing their own crude, the money stays within the same corporate family:
When WCS prices are low: The upstream mining division loses revenue, but the US refining division buys cheap feedstock and captures massive profit margins on the refined products (gasoline, diesel, aviation fuel).
When WCS prices are high: The upstream division rakes in cash, while the refining margins compress.
Because of this natural hedge, integrated oil companies generate stable, multibillion-dollar profits regardless of transmission bottlenecks or price volatility. They are structurally protected from the very problem a new pipeline claims to fix.
2. Diversion to Asia is Actively Counterproductive
For an integrated producer, spending tens of billions to divert crude away from their own US refineries toward Asian markets makes no commercial sense:
Starving Their Own Assets: Diverting WCS to the Pacific coast means US refineries would have to buy heavier crude from more expensive or less reliable international sources (like Mexico or Venezuela) to keep their units running.
Destroying Refining Margins: If a new pipeline successfully bids up the price of WCS in North America by creating a supply shortage for US refiners, it directly harms the profitability of the Canadian oil companies' own US refining operations.
This seems to the compelling reason that the Pathway oil companies, mostly US owned, are not interested in investing.
I write this as a resident of Alberta who has watched [Warning! Pejorative (but incredibly valid) opinion follows!] the reign of folly that has occurred since 2015 and that was aimed specifically at Alberta and it's oil industry with the aim of shutting down our industry. [Don't believe me? Refer to the Face Painter's 2017 comments.]
Please allow me to work through the answer to the question in your headline.
Okay, so you want to know where the oil will come from?
Oh, why don't you argue that there isn't a private sector proponent for a pipeline as so many foolishly have argued for some years? To that I respectfully point out that there isn't a private sector proponent because there is currently a law that makes unlawful the earning of a profit from such a pipeline. You argue that there isn't such a law? You are wrong! How does a pipeline operator earn a profit? That profit is earned by charging a fee to transport oil. In this case, no resource company will sign up to transport any such oil because the law will not allow it to be sold. Will not allow it to be sold? Balderdash! you respond. I simply respond by saying that there is a law that prohibits loading oil on a tanker on the northwest coast of BC. If you cannot load the oil no one will buy it and if it is not sold then it will not be shipped and, consequently, the pipeline operator will not earn a profit.
So, why is that law against loading oil in place when MC has asserted that he wants Canada to be an energy superpower? Well, he also has said that - perhaps - he will vary that law - on a case by case basis - for an approved major project. Perhaps. A pipeline requires many, many hundreds of billions of dollars to be committed and expended BEFORE a pipeline begins construction. The pipeline industry has collectively lost billions of dollars due to the government whims and rejections and changes and withdrawals of previous approvals, etc. over the previous years since the Face Painter commenced his reign of error. Why should the pipeline companies simply agree to lose more with the law preventing a profit still in place, a law that will "perhaps" be lifted on a case by case basis?
So, if you want a private sector proponent, simply eliminate the ban on loading oil on the northwest BC coast. Then, then, then you will see a private sector proponent.
Now, let's get back to your question as to where the oil will come from. The answer is that the oil will come from the oil sands. Currently, the oil sands operators are sitting on their hands with respect to expansion of facilities. Why are they sitting on their hands? Why, there is a law that prevents the sale of oil delivered. In other words, it is the same problem for finding a private sector proponent for a pipeline.
Yes, there are other pipeline projects being initiated, largely, so-called optimization and relatively minor expansion projects.
On the other hand, you ask, what about yet more production? Danielle Smith has many times stated that it is her goal that Alberta oil production will double to eight million barrels per day by 2035, with an interim target of six million barrels a day by 2030. So, there is the production that you have asked about.
If there is to be additional production, both the producers and the pipeline operators have to be legally allowed to make a profit. To make a profit, the law banning tanker operations must go.
Once that law goes and once it is clear that a real opportunity for profit exists - not the illusory situation under the Face Painter and as exists now - then the only issue will be whether the resource and pipeline companies can raise the capital themselves. Note, I said "themselves" and I did not in any way reference government financial support.
So, if you want your question answered the foolish law that was imposed so recently must go. You argue that the commercial case for investment is dependent on analysis of future demand. You are wrong, Sir! There is no demand if profit is prohibited. If you want the industry to prove it's case, make profit possible.
Now that the south route has been selected, everything you just said is complete, unadulterated, polyunsaturated bullshit. The tanker ban does not apply to Robert's Bank. It never has. Therefore your claim that the oil can't be shipped so it can't be sold is total nonsense. In fact, it is being shipped weekly a short distance away in Burnaby through the LIBERAL Government built Transmountan pipeline. Furthermore, that pipeline isn't even full yet. And none of the oil sands producers are announcing production expansions to fill it. So you're "if the taxpayers build it they will come" arguent just isn't delivering.
The south route/Robert's Bank solution has been known about for over 25 years. So tell me, Mr. Schultz, why the Harper government didn't build this line 20 years ago, in 2006, when the massive oil patch expansion was roaring ahead. Just like today, you wouldn't have had near the indigenous opposition to a doubled Trans Mountain. A million bpd pipeline coming on stream in 2011 would have diverted almost all that expanded production offshore at full world prices for bitumen. It would have been an absolute windfall for the oil sands stockholders. Let's not kid ourselves, it would still have cost at least $25 billion due to competing with massive oil sands consumption of labor and equipment, but like their projects, it would have gotten done. The only catch would have been a Federal Government willing to cough up the $5 billion to build a VLCC capable Robert's Bank terminal. Clearly, you can't count on a Federal Conservative Government to have that kind of vision and the fiscal management skills to make it happen. All you can count on them, and you, for, is endless ranting about an impractical and vastly environmentally destructive, totally unnecessary, northern route. All you've really done for the last 10 years is waste everyone's time. After Trans Mountain 1, you're also just further proof that if you want anything done in this country, it takes a LIBERAL Government to do it. Which is a tragedy, because no Party is so perfect that they should stay in power forever. But you keep on proving endlessly that the Conservative Party just doesn't have the skill set to be trusted with Government.
you forget the other regulatory obstacles like Eby, Indigenous groups whose land the pipeline never touches, carbon bullshit fees, etc. If we were serious about this we could rake in royalties to the government that would support all kinds of stupid climate initiatives that Mr. Nicholson can dream up. Or we can just wait for China to take over all our industries and we can learn Mandarin so we can say we are so progressive in Chinese.
The point is that if the project doesn't have a prospect of a profit then it will not be proposed and it is only once proposed that that stupid stuff kicks in. Further, if the projected profit is sufficient, the proponent will fight it and - with luck - will come out the other side victorious but nobody, nobody will even get into the fight if there is no prospect of profit.
Except it ignores the scientific realities of climate change — and Canada's responsibility and commitments to meet its inadequate emissions targets.
Fossil-fuel expansion dooms Canada's climate targets for decades. These goals are simply incompatible.
Neither the IPCC nor the IEA endorses fossil fuel expansion — the basis of Corporate Canada's plan to fail on climate.
We don't have decades to expand fossil fuel production.
The IPCC warns that the world must nearly halve GHG emissions by 2030 and eliminate them by 2050 to keep warming below the threshold of 1.5 C.
IEA's Net-Zero by 2050 report says no new investment in fossil fuels after 2021 to limit global warming to 1.5 C.
No time for fossil-fuel expansion.
Transitions start by moving in the direction you wish to travel. Doubling down on fossil fuels takes us in the wrong direction. When you're in a hole, stop digging.
No energy transition is possible until we start producing and using less fossil fuels. Renewables must displace fossil fuels, not merely add to them.
Canada's climate targets are unachievable without a phase-out of fossil-fuel production.
The real question is: Shall Canada exempt itself from meeting its climate targets?
Mark Carney's answer is a resounding YES.
If Canada exempts itself from meeting its climate targets, why should other countries not follow suit?
Yes the hundreds of billions of $$ for new production, plus the $40ish billion for a new pipeline do not 1) seem to be gushing forth to be spent by private equity, and 2) seem needed as we transition over the next 75 years to a mainly electrified world, it requires a very rosy set of glasses to suggest additional production will have a market.
As such while governments may approve a "framework" to enable this possibility, and counter the loud unproductive rhetoric from our separatist Premier, it has no role in financing what increasingly looks to be unnecessary.
Public $$ have so many much more useful and important places to be used to support Canadians and Canada!
This is a discussion that should only occur AFTER our country has properly started to address climate change. The idea that we might somehow rationalize increasing oil sands production is lunacy. I’ve no doubt the author understands the economics of pipelines and export-destinations perfectly, but he should make a similar effort to understand how his children and grandchildren will survive a world once climactic tipping points have been reached. THIS IS EXACTLY THE WRONG DISCUSSION TO BE HAVING.
I’d add that Carbon Capture & Sequestration is an absolute fraud. It is unproven technology that has not in any way come close to demonstrating that such capture and sequestration is remotely possible. We need to wake up and take climate change seriously, and this kind of discussion isn’t helpful.
Finally, some great info on the big picture. A pipeline is the cart before the horse. And who knows what the market will look like after Hormuz? Talking about a pipeline is a waste of time and valuable energy. The world oil market and Alberta are in turmoil and no smart investor will bet on that.
Interesting read however it mostly comes across as a litany of reasons why an additional oil pipeline to the West Coast should never be built. Pretty much what you expect from someone who worked with the Trudeau government. No wonder many people in Alberta are resentful of what came out of Ottawa in the past. Is the Carney government any different? We shall see.
Either you didn’t read what the author wrote about his career or you didn’t understand what he said. He never said he worked for any government, Harper’s or Trudeau’s, he SAID he had worked in the oil industry! As an insider I’ll take his expertise over EVERYONE who does not have that knowledge,or expertise and who IMMEDIATELY, decided to bring up Trudeau! Is there something mentally wrong with right wing Albertans that their go to complaint is to ALWAYS bring up Trudeau? Talk about Trudeau derangement syndrome!
Not to mention that BC is NOT interested in having another pipeline shoved up our ass without our permission and most certainly NOT in the closed off NO TANKERS area! We actually prefer to PROTECT OUR PROVINCE as opposed to so many Albertans who think Oil is the only,y important hint on the bloody planet!
I think you are to quick to dismiss the first oil source, diversion.
An oil pipeline to the west coast won't be ready for a decade. In that time, EVs and PHEV will grow market share, even in the US.
Industry projections already place Midwest refining capacity as falling by nearly a million barrels; improvements to the Enbridge Mainline do nothing when the concern is falling regional demand.
Maybe Southbow will get more access to the Gulf Coast built. We would still be entirely at the whim of any energy tariff or US decision to ban crude oil exports, but at least it would be a structurally stable market. But then again, Keystone XL was supposed to do that before being blocked by a jurisdiction we have no ability to control.
Only TMX enhancements offers any real chance of growth into long-term stable markets right now. That won't cover the expected brownfield production growth, let alone adsorb the supply being blocked in by falling demand.
I also think when discussing Asia you are to generic. China is rapidly electrifying transport. It's also building heavy oil refineries. Why? Because the future of the oil market is heavy barrels, even if overall demand falls, the need will be jet fuel, asphalt, lubricants, and other heavy RPPs.
As the demand for gasoline collapses, refiners will shun lighter crudes that are gasoline rich in favor of grades like bitumen. We already see that in Europe as it exports gasoline and closes older tea kettle refineries.
I'm most shocked you would argue for the LNG. I my opinion, global demand for heavy oil and collapsing demand in our current regional market are sure things. LNG on the otherhand is running full speed to glut. I can imagine buyers putting a premium on Canada for Environmental/security reasons, but I am by no means sure or confident. While we have cheap NG, and while the oilsands creates demand for condensate that supports the proposition, getting it over a mountain range is a lot harder than our competitors have to deal with.
I know next to nothing about the industry but am curious why there isn't more discussion about increasing refinement in Canada vs. shipping more crude.
Wouldn't this;
Ease dependency on US for the finished products
Save Canadian citizens $
Make Canadian industries more competitive by also saving them $
A very useful contribution to the debate, shifting the focus on the oil industry willingness to commit large amount of capital in greenfield production, not on its transportation by pipeline.
As a now long retired petroleum economist I find this article to be most accurate in all respects. A couple of tangential points: the current level of oil sands production results from the huge investments over largely the period 2005 - 2015. This growth was significantly assisted by taxpayers and resource owners through tax and royalty relief. Many see this relief as a subsidy. I am one of these. The production growth from these subsidies has been impressive. However these subsidies brought on line higher cost production that would have otherwise been uncompetitive, and they lead to increased costs for all sectors of the economy. There is a fine line between subsidizing and assisting. Industry will always see regulatory relief and taxpayer input as justified and never as a subsidy. Industry too will see the correct policy desire for Canada to become an energy superpower as an opportunity to squeeze a few more dollars out of taxpayers. By the way, Canada already is a world energy superpower! A final word on subsidies/taxpayer help. It is entirely legitimate for governments to assist industry expansion. A question in this regard is: will taxpayers be entitled to a return on their investment or will their investment simply be a subsidy.
People are finally starting to ask the right question. Do the oil sands producers want this pipeline? All evidence to date demonstrates a complete lack of enthusiasm.
As noted, there is over one million barrels per day of new or optimized pipeline capacity in the pipeline, so to speak. That's almost a 30% increase over current production. This ephemeral pipeline will serve the next million barrels, an almost 60% increase in production in less than a decade! The total price will be well over $100 billion, dwarfing the costs of the pipeline itself, at a time when companies are relentlessly cutting costs.
If the producers aren't willing to declare their full support for this initiative then why is this farce, and the divisiveness it is causing, allowed to continue?
well said !
And.......a business case for a future oilsands expansion would need to include the cost of cleanup, which this time, we should insist is paid during the fe9nt end of production.
That's also something that would affect production in the current brownfield. As they mature, the amount set aside for clean up increases. Which might affect some operations production schedule.
Excellent analysis. Perhaps a “must read” for Premier Smith?
I would urge the Feds to believe this. And just ... call their bluff. Mollify your green fans by saying that you're calling a bluff, that you don't believe they'll take you up on this: drop the CCS requirement entirely, drop the tanker ban, for any project that sells newly-produced oil.
Take away their scapegoat. Reveal the simple truth in this article: the business case has gone. And it is not coming back.
Every 2 million eVs sold reduce the global oil demand by just 0.1Mbbl/d. But they will sell about 24M eVs this year, and take 1.2Mbbl/d away from the market. Batteries have progressed to where China and some other countries are electrifying trucks, too; and ferries; and short-haul cargo boats. The Hormuz Crisis has only stimulated this switch.
‘the tanker ban’ is the dogmatic warcry of the misinformed - fed by the likes of Andrew Sheer, Smith & Poilievre Inc - sure.. just Delete International Navigational Law re some of the most Dangerous Waters on Spaceship Earth & why in hell would an actual Supertanker Skipper want to ? To go exactly where ? Delivering or picking up what Load ?
The elephant in the room needs to be addressed. For the actual owners of the oil sands, the status quo—where they control both the tap and the drain—is exactly how they maximize global profit.
The conventional political argument in Canada is that without an Asian outlet, Canadian heavy crude (Western Canadian Select, or WCS) suffers from a steep price discount compared to US West Texas Intermediate (WTI), hurting the Canadian economy.
While a wide WCS-WTI discount hurts a pure upstream producer, it is a massive windfall for a refiner configured to process heavy, sour crude. Because Canadian majors own the US refineries processing their own crude, the money stays within the same corporate family:
When WCS prices are low: The upstream mining division loses revenue, but the US refining division buys cheap feedstock and captures massive profit margins on the refined products (gasoline, diesel, aviation fuel).
When WCS prices are high: The upstream division rakes in cash, while the refining margins compress.
Because of this natural hedge, integrated oil companies generate stable, multibillion-dollar profits regardless of transmission bottlenecks or price volatility. They are structurally protected from the very problem a new pipeline claims to fix.
2. Diversion to Asia is Actively Counterproductive
For an integrated producer, spending tens of billions to divert crude away from their own US refineries toward Asian markets makes no commercial sense:
Starving Their Own Assets: Diverting WCS to the Pacific coast means US refineries would have to buy heavier crude from more expensive or less reliable international sources (like Mexico or Venezuela) to keep their units running.
Destroying Refining Margins: If a new pipeline successfully bids up the price of WCS in North America by creating a supply shortage for US refiners, it directly harms the profitability of the Canadian oil companies' own US refining operations.
This seems to the compelling reason that the Pathway oil companies, mostly US owned, are not interested in investing.
I write this as a resident of Alberta who has watched [Warning! Pejorative (but incredibly valid) opinion follows!] the reign of folly that has occurred since 2015 and that was aimed specifically at Alberta and it's oil industry with the aim of shutting down our industry. [Don't believe me? Refer to the Face Painter's 2017 comments.]
Please allow me to work through the answer to the question in your headline.
Okay, so you want to know where the oil will come from?
Oh, why don't you argue that there isn't a private sector proponent for a pipeline as so many foolishly have argued for some years? To that I respectfully point out that there isn't a private sector proponent because there is currently a law that makes unlawful the earning of a profit from such a pipeline. You argue that there isn't such a law? You are wrong! How does a pipeline operator earn a profit? That profit is earned by charging a fee to transport oil. In this case, no resource company will sign up to transport any such oil because the law will not allow it to be sold. Will not allow it to be sold? Balderdash! you respond. I simply respond by saying that there is a law that prohibits loading oil on a tanker on the northwest coast of BC. If you cannot load the oil no one will buy it and if it is not sold then it will not be shipped and, consequently, the pipeline operator will not earn a profit.
So, why is that law against loading oil in place when MC has asserted that he wants Canada to be an energy superpower? Well, he also has said that - perhaps - he will vary that law - on a case by case basis - for an approved major project. Perhaps. A pipeline requires many, many hundreds of billions of dollars to be committed and expended BEFORE a pipeline begins construction. The pipeline industry has collectively lost billions of dollars due to the government whims and rejections and changes and withdrawals of previous approvals, etc. over the previous years since the Face Painter commenced his reign of error. Why should the pipeline companies simply agree to lose more with the law preventing a profit still in place, a law that will "perhaps" be lifted on a case by case basis?
So, if you want a private sector proponent, simply eliminate the ban on loading oil on the northwest BC coast. Then, then, then you will see a private sector proponent.
Now, let's get back to your question as to where the oil will come from. The answer is that the oil will come from the oil sands. Currently, the oil sands operators are sitting on their hands with respect to expansion of facilities. Why are they sitting on their hands? Why, there is a law that prevents the sale of oil delivered. In other words, it is the same problem for finding a private sector proponent for a pipeline.
Yes, there are other pipeline projects being initiated, largely, so-called optimization and relatively minor expansion projects.
On the other hand, you ask, what about yet more production? Danielle Smith has many times stated that it is her goal that Alberta oil production will double to eight million barrels per day by 2035, with an interim target of six million barrels a day by 2030. So, there is the production that you have asked about.
If there is to be additional production, both the producers and the pipeline operators have to be legally allowed to make a profit. To make a profit, the law banning tanker operations must go.
Once that law goes and once it is clear that a real opportunity for profit exists - not the illusory situation under the Face Painter and as exists now - then the only issue will be whether the resource and pipeline companies can raise the capital themselves. Note, I said "themselves" and I did not in any way reference government financial support.
So, if you want your question answered the foolish law that was imposed so recently must go. You argue that the commercial case for investment is dependent on analysis of future demand. You are wrong, Sir! There is no demand if profit is prohibited. If you want the industry to prove it's case, make profit possible.
Now that the south route has been selected, everything you just said is complete, unadulterated, polyunsaturated bullshit. The tanker ban does not apply to Robert's Bank. It never has. Therefore your claim that the oil can't be shipped so it can't be sold is total nonsense. In fact, it is being shipped weekly a short distance away in Burnaby through the LIBERAL Government built Transmountan pipeline. Furthermore, that pipeline isn't even full yet. And none of the oil sands producers are announcing production expansions to fill it. So you're "if the taxpayers build it they will come" arguent just isn't delivering.
The south route/Robert's Bank solution has been known about for over 25 years. So tell me, Mr. Schultz, why the Harper government didn't build this line 20 years ago, in 2006, when the massive oil patch expansion was roaring ahead. Just like today, you wouldn't have had near the indigenous opposition to a doubled Trans Mountain. A million bpd pipeline coming on stream in 2011 would have diverted almost all that expanded production offshore at full world prices for bitumen. It would have been an absolute windfall for the oil sands stockholders. Let's not kid ourselves, it would still have cost at least $25 billion due to competing with massive oil sands consumption of labor and equipment, but like their projects, it would have gotten done. The only catch would have been a Federal Government willing to cough up the $5 billion to build a VLCC capable Robert's Bank terminal. Clearly, you can't count on a Federal Conservative Government to have that kind of vision and the fiscal management skills to make it happen. All you can count on them, and you, for, is endless ranting about an impractical and vastly environmentally destructive, totally unnecessary, northern route. All you've really done for the last 10 years is waste everyone's time. After Trans Mountain 1, you're also just further proof that if you want anything done in this country, it takes a LIBERAL Government to do it. Which is a tragedy, because no Party is so perfect that they should stay in power forever. But you keep on proving endlessly that the Conservative Party just doesn't have the skill set to be trusted with Government.
you forget the other regulatory obstacles like Eby, Indigenous groups whose land the pipeline never touches, carbon bullshit fees, etc. If we were serious about this we could rake in royalties to the government that would support all kinds of stupid climate initiatives that Mr. Nicholson can dream up. Or we can just wait for China to take over all our industries and we can learn Mandarin so we can say we are so progressive in Chinese.
No, Dan, I don't forget that garbage whatsoever.
The point is that if the project doesn't have a prospect of a profit then it will not be proposed and it is only once proposed that that stupid stuff kicks in. Further, if the projected profit is sufficient, the proponent will fight it and - with luck - will come out the other side victorious but nobody, nobody will even get into the fight if there is no prospect of profit.
Cheers, Dan.
Astute analysis.
Except it ignores the scientific realities of climate change — and Canada's responsibility and commitments to meet its inadequate emissions targets.
Fossil-fuel expansion dooms Canada's climate targets for decades. These goals are simply incompatible.
Neither the IPCC nor the IEA endorses fossil fuel expansion — the basis of Corporate Canada's plan to fail on climate.
We don't have decades to expand fossil fuel production.
The IPCC warns that the world must nearly halve GHG emissions by 2030 and eliminate them by 2050 to keep warming below the threshold of 1.5 C.
IEA's Net-Zero by 2050 report says no new investment in fossil fuels after 2021 to limit global warming to 1.5 C.
No time for fossil-fuel expansion.
Transitions start by moving in the direction you wish to travel. Doubling down on fossil fuels takes us in the wrong direction. When you're in a hole, stop digging.
No energy transition is possible until we start producing and using less fossil fuels. Renewables must displace fossil fuels, not merely add to them.
Canada's climate targets are unachievable without a phase-out of fossil-fuel production.
The real question is: Shall Canada exempt itself from meeting its climate targets?
Mark Carney's answer is a resounding YES.
If Canada exempts itself from meeting its climate targets, why should other countries not follow suit?
A sprint over the climate cliff.
Selling our grandkids down the river.
Reckless and irresponsible.
Yes the hundreds of billions of $$ for new production, plus the $40ish billion for a new pipeline do not 1) seem to be gushing forth to be spent by private equity, and 2) seem needed as we transition over the next 75 years to a mainly electrified world, it requires a very rosy set of glasses to suggest additional production will have a market.
As such while governments may approve a "framework" to enable this possibility, and counter the loud unproductive rhetoric from our separatist Premier, it has no role in financing what increasingly looks to be unnecessary.
Public $$ have so many much more useful and important places to be used to support Canadians and Canada!
This is a discussion that should only occur AFTER our country has properly started to address climate change. The idea that we might somehow rationalize increasing oil sands production is lunacy. I’ve no doubt the author understands the economics of pipelines and export-destinations perfectly, but he should make a similar effort to understand how his children and grandchildren will survive a world once climactic tipping points have been reached. THIS IS EXACTLY THE WRONG DISCUSSION TO BE HAVING.
I’d add that Carbon Capture & Sequestration is an absolute fraud. It is unproven technology that has not in any way come close to demonstrating that such capture and sequestration is remotely possible. We need to wake up and take climate change seriously, and this kind of discussion isn’t helpful.
Finally, some great info on the big picture. A pipeline is the cart before the horse. And who knows what the market will look like after Hormuz? Talking about a pipeline is a waste of time and valuable energy. The world oil market and Alberta are in turmoil and no smart investor will bet on that.
and the environmental cost of new oil sands, plus new pipelines. . . . for what is really short-term benefit? It’s a hard NO from me.
Interesting read however it mostly comes across as a litany of reasons why an additional oil pipeline to the West Coast should never be built. Pretty much what you expect from someone who worked with the Trudeau government. No wonder many people in Alberta are resentful of what came out of Ottawa in the past. Is the Carney government any different? We shall see.
Either you didn’t read what the author wrote about his career or you didn’t understand what he said. He never said he worked for any government, Harper’s or Trudeau’s, he SAID he had worked in the oil industry! As an insider I’ll take his expertise over EVERYONE who does not have that knowledge,or expertise and who IMMEDIATELY, decided to bring up Trudeau! Is there something mentally wrong with right wing Albertans that their go to complaint is to ALWAYS bring up Trudeau? Talk about Trudeau derangement syndrome!
Not to mention that BC is NOT interested in having another pipeline shoved up our ass without our permission and most certainly NOT in the closed off NO TANKERS area! We actually prefer to PROTECT OUR PROVINCE as opposed to so many Albertans who think Oil is the only,y important hint on the bloody planet!
I think you are to quick to dismiss the first oil source, diversion.
An oil pipeline to the west coast won't be ready for a decade. In that time, EVs and PHEV will grow market share, even in the US.
Industry projections already place Midwest refining capacity as falling by nearly a million barrels; improvements to the Enbridge Mainline do nothing when the concern is falling regional demand.
Maybe Southbow will get more access to the Gulf Coast built. We would still be entirely at the whim of any energy tariff or US decision to ban crude oil exports, but at least it would be a structurally stable market. But then again, Keystone XL was supposed to do that before being blocked by a jurisdiction we have no ability to control.
Only TMX enhancements offers any real chance of growth into long-term stable markets right now. That won't cover the expected brownfield production growth, let alone adsorb the supply being blocked in by falling demand.
I also think when discussing Asia you are to generic. China is rapidly electrifying transport. It's also building heavy oil refineries. Why? Because the future of the oil market is heavy barrels, even if overall demand falls, the need will be jet fuel, asphalt, lubricants, and other heavy RPPs.
As the demand for gasoline collapses, refiners will shun lighter crudes that are gasoline rich in favor of grades like bitumen. We already see that in Europe as it exports gasoline and closes older tea kettle refineries.
I'm most shocked you would argue for the LNG. I my opinion, global demand for heavy oil and collapsing demand in our current regional market are sure things. LNG on the otherhand is running full speed to glut. I can imagine buyers putting a premium on Canada for Environmental/security reasons, but I am by no means sure or confident. While we have cheap NG, and while the oilsands creates demand for condensate that supports the proposition, getting it over a mountain range is a lot harder than our competitors have to deal with.
I know next to nothing about the industry but am curious why there isn't more discussion about increasing refinement in Canada vs. shipping more crude.
Wouldn't this;
Ease dependency on US for the finished products
Save Canadian citizens $
Make Canadian industries more competitive by also saving them $
Avoid encroachment on indigenous lands
Have less environmental disruption