Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ken Wilson's avatar

A word of caution. Leading Western jurisdictions that have embraced the green energy measures recommended by Peter Nicolson, such as California, the UK and Germany, all have very high energy prices.

In all cases, these high energy prices beget some combination of high taxes, high subsidies, and high indebtedness. This, in turn, is causing a de-industrialization process that is having a serious impact on those at the lower end of the economic scale who are the ones losing their jobs and experiencing a real drop in their standard of living. This, in turn, is causing major social stresses within these leading green energy jurisdictions and falling revenues for their governments.

A couple of months ago, Chancellor Mertz stated that Germany could no longer afford its social programs.

A couple of years ago, President Xi stated that China would not fully embrace green energy measures until they are confident that these green energy measures can meet China’s need for secure reliable energy sources in the future. In the meantime, China is busily building new coal fired power plants and nuclear power plants. It is also researching new nuclear plant designs for future use.

The crux of the matter is that green energy measures are inherently intermittent and unstable. If these form a major part of a nation’s installed electrical capacity and if they are given priority access to a national energy grid, then they are highly destabilizing to a national energy grid that relies on dispatchable power sources.

This means that a modern nation that requires secure reliable power 24/7 has to maintain two power systems, one for when the sun shines and the wind blows and the other for when it doesn’t. This creates two costly power systems, both of which are now inefficient and costly to run.

This mixed energy system is destroying national economies as we can see in Europe today. I hope Canada does not go down this same damaging green energy path.

Mike's avatar

Another factor that is becoming increasingly important. Renewables are more secure geopolitically. Oil needs to be refined, and even places with big oil reserves may not have the refining capacity to be self sufficient. If you look at what's going on on Cuba, that should serve as a warning.

I also view remaining dependent on fossil fuel extraction as a revenue source is an opportunity cost. If we can switch to power that is more easily generated like wind and solar it FREES us up to do so many other things that could enrich our lives.

13 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?